Battery Park Dining Guide: Hidden Gems and Favorites

Battery Park City, on the Hudson River in Lower Manhattan, blends urban sophistication and waterfront tranquility. Its dining scene reflects this duality, from casual eateries perfect for a quick bite to upscale venues ideal for special occasions. The neighborhood's proximity to significant landmarks like the Statue of Liberty ferry and the Financial District also influences its restaurant offerings, attracting both residents and a steady stream of visitors.

This guide delves into some of the most notable dining establishments in this bustling part of New York City, highlighting their unique characteristics and what makes them stand out.

Lox Cafe, located within the Museum of Jewish Heritage in Battery Park City, is something of a hidden gem. Its setting is unique, and the menu at this kosher restaurant goes beyond traditional deli fare. The culinary approach at Lox Cafe involves in-house curing of salmon, resulting in a unique range of lox options, including vodka-infused dill lox and grapefruit and gin varieties. Signature offerings like the "lox five ways" platter, served with various cream cheeses, fresh vegetables, and a bread basket, provide a comprehensive tasting experience.

Inatteso Pizzabar, whose name translates to "unexpected" in Italian, positions itself as more than just a casual pizza place in Battery Park City. Its Neapolitan and “della nonna” pizzas are a core offering, and tapioca-based vegan cheese pizzas are also available. Beyond pizza, they offer handmade pastas, seasonal fruits and vegetables, all-natural meats, wild seafood, and imported cheeses. The all-Italian wine list features organic and small-production producers. Its location offers views of the Freedom Tower and the Battery Park esplanade.

ER HOT POT brings the interactive and communal experience of traditional Chinese hot pot to Battery Park City. This restaurant invites diners to participate in a shared meal, where they cook their choice of meats and vegetables in simmering broths at the table. Diners gather around a communal pot, selecting from a range of marbled meats and fresh vegetables to cook in their chosen broth. The experience is enhanced by a selection of personalized dipping sauces, allowing each individual to tailor the flavors to their preference.

Mezze on the River presents a Mediterranean-inspired, waterfront dining concept in Battery Park City. This establishment offers a fresh perspective on Mediterranean, Greek, and seafood dishes, leveraging its prime location overlooking the Hudson River. The dedicated mixology team curates a selection of seasonal cocktails designed to complement the dishes. Mezze on the River strives to create a warm and inviting atmosphere suitable for intimate dinners or special occasions, providing an exquisite dining experience with stunning water views.

Schilling Restaurant & Bar, located in the Financial District near Battery Park City, offers a contemporary take on Austrian fare. Chef Eduard Frauneder, known for his Michelin-starred work, brings a refined approach to classic dishes in a day-to-night bistro setting. The menu features dishes such as Wiener Schnitzel, prepared with heritage pork or organic chicken, served with cucumber dill salad and potato salad. Spätzle with butternut squash, roasted broccoli rabe, and Apple Strudel with walnuts and vanilla sauce are notable offerings. A menu of classic cocktails, crafted by the team behind The Third Man, complements the food.

The White Horse Tavern in the Financial District, near Battery Park City, is considered New York City's second-oldest bar, established in 1880. It has long been a place for gathering, celebrating, and commiserating, maintaining the feel of a classic, authentic pub. Originally a hangout for dock workers by the Hudson River, the White Horse Tavern became a prominent hotspot for writers and artists in the 1950s. The pub offers a full menu and a comprehensive cocktail menu, including lunch, evening, and weekend options. It also provides a large private floor for group events, allowing patrons to immerse themselves in a piece of New York City's past while enjoying a meal or a drink.

Fraunces Tavern, located at the corner of Pearl and Broad Streets, is a National Historic Landmark and museum that played a pivotal role in American history. Initially built in 1719, it was purchased by Samuel Fraunces in 1762 and operated as a boarding house with a bar. The tavern is famous for being the site where George Washington bid farewell to his officers in 1783. It also housed the first offices for the Departments of Foreign Affairs, War, and Treasury. Today, Fraunces Tavern operates as a restaurant and bar, offering thoughtfully prepared American cuisine focusing on farm-to-table ingredients. It boasts seven distinct spaces, including the Dingle Whiskey Bar, The Wine Room, and The Washington Room for private dining.

Trinity Place offers a unique dining experience within a turn-of-the-century Wall Street bank vault. Commissioned by Andrew Carnegie and advertised in 1904 as the world's largest and strongest bank vault, this venue combines modern American cuisine with the grandeur of Old World splendor. The restaurant and bar are built directly inside the massive vault, providing an atmosphere that is both intimate and awe-inspiring, complete with thick steel doors and ornate detailing. The menu features modern American cuisine with influences from Irish dishes, offering a sophisticated selection of entrees, appetizers, and desserts.

Harry's has been a trusted institution since 1972. It is known for its classic American options, from juicy burgers and fresh salads to hearty steakhouse selections. Their menu also includes an extensive raw bar with oysters, clams, and lobster cocktails. Signature dishes often feature prime steaks and a selection of seafood. Harry's also provides vegetarian and gluten-free options. It is known for its ability to host both midday business meetings and after-work drinks.

Treadwell Park boasts an extensive and rotating selection of craft beers and ciders on tap, often delivered through a unique "flux capacitor" system. The food menu features American comfort dishes, including tender brisket sliders, various pork and chicken options, and indulgent lobster ravioli. Beyond food and drink, Treadwell Park offers a lively ambiance complemented by numerous big-screen TVs for sports viewing and a game room equipped with pinball machines and ping pong tables. This combination of culinary offerings, craft beverages, and entertainment makes Treadwell Park a dynamic destination.

Whether you're buying, selling, or investing in New York City, Kobi Lahav brings an exceptional blend of experience, negotiation expertise, and global perspective to help you succeed. As Senior Managing Director at Living NY, Kobi leads with integrity, dedication, and a client-first approach, serving Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens.

When you work with Kobi, you're choosing a seasoned professional who is passionate about results and people. Reach out today.